Nicole Ronchetti
The Bemidji Pioneer, Minn.
(TNS)
Jan. 31—BEMIDJI — The Bemidji City Council heard a report on the future of city hall and the fire station during its meeting on Monday, which included six options ranging in cost from $23 to $26 million.
Conversations on the buildings’ future began last spring, after the lower levels of city hall flooded in late April 2022.
The following inspection revealed several other concerns related to drainage, including issues with the roof and foundation.
Presented with these problems, the city council agreed to conduct an evaluation of its options, which included remodeling the building or constructing a new Bemidji City Hall.
The Bemidji Fire Department, which had previously raised concerns about the fire station’s aging conditions and lack of adequate space, asked to also be included in the evaluation.
Wold Architects and Engineers was brought in to conduct the study and after nine months of interviews and planning, two representatives gave a report to the council on its options.
“This is at a good inflection point for the project,” said John McNamara, a partner at Wold. “(We’re) really thinking through what the long-term needs for the city are.”
McNamara and Wold architect Paige Sullivan presented the council members with six options for them to consider, all of which included remodeling or reconstructing both buildings.
Each of the options would increase the space in the buildings, increasing city hall from around 12,000 square feet to 18,000 and the fire station from 10,000 to 24,000 square feet.
“There really is no space left,” McNamara explained, outlining the lack of usable space for offices, storage and other key functions. “That’s something that needs to be addressed.”
Option 1, which was the only alternative that would remodel the existing buildings, would renovate some of the existing spaces and add significant additions to both city hall and the fire station.
The construction of this option would cost an estimated $23,206,000, but it would also require the purchase and demolition of the First National Bank branch, which currently exists on the same block as both municipal buildings. These costs were not included in the estimate.
Options 2 and 3 similarly would require the demolition of the bank, the cost of which was also not included in the estimates of $26,028,000 for either option.
Unlike Option 1, both of these options would create an entirely new combined facility for city hall and the fire station and construction would be done in phases.
Options 4a and 4b were both created with designs that would allow for the continued existence of the neighboring bank, and similarly would create a new combined facility. The cost estimates for both options come in at $26 million.
Both 4a and 4b could be constructed in phases to allow for as much continued operation of the current buildings as possible.
“That’s why we wanted to include options here that would allow a phased approach,” McNamara shared.
The final alternative presented to the council, Option 5, would construct entirely new facilities on a separate site at the estimated cost of $25.5 million. This estimate assumes the use of land the city already owns.
While all of these cost estimates, barring some expenses that were not included, fell within a similar range, one of the first things acknowledged by the council was the cost of the project.
“That’s a lot of money that comes from the taxpayer, one way or another,” said Mayor Jorge Prince, who explained that Bemidji is already facing large government projects from the county and school district.
Ward 4 Coun