Menu

Welcome

The Finest Supporting the Bravest!

The purpose of the Fire Mechanics Section is to promote standardization of fire apparatus and equipment preventative maintenance, improve safety standards and practices, promote workshops, conferences, and seminars related to the purposes of this Section, and to promote cost savings through standardization of building and equipment purchasing and maintenance.

RECENT FIRE MECHANIC NEWS

Posted: Apr 1, 2018

Fire Apparatus Electric Valves: I Don’t Like Them

Editor’s Note: Every department has its own reasons for specifying certain components on its fire apparatus, including valves on a pumper. In recent years, electric valve use for intakes and discharges has increased. However, there is still a large contingent in the fire service that prefers valves with manual linkages. This month, we asked Editorial Advisory Board members Ricky Riley (left) and Bill Adams (right) to comment on electric and manual valves.

My views on electric valves are biased and outdated and do not reflect current products or trends. Some older acquaintances still in the industry and fire service have similar sentiments—so do those uneducated on the subject. Their opinions are incorporated into my narration. To temper my predisposed views, I sought input from Jason Witmier, northeast regional sales manager for Safe Fleet (representing FRC, Elkhart Brass, ROM, and FoamPro). Witmier previously worked for KME as a product manager for 14 years.

The term electric valve is a misnomer. Most valves are the same. It’s the controller that is either manually moved or activated by air, electricity, or hydraulic power (see photo). Discounting mechanical sirens and beacon rays, I dislike most electronics on fire apparatus. Manual levers, linkages, and pull-rods appear fail-safe. And when engaged, they give assurance that something is happening. Assurance is felt, heard, and seen. It can be the resistance (pressure) against a valve, the sound of water moving, or watching pressure gauge needles moving. You don’t sense that with electric valves. Besides, you can have a broken wire, a malfunctioning switch, a stuck valve, a malfunctioning visual screen, or a burned-out indicator light.

1 In the mid 1980s, the former Young Fire Apparatus delivered custom chassied pumpers with hydraulically operated valves on pump panels remotely located from the front-mounted pump. When questioned, owner Dick Young stated, “Well, we used a hydraulically operated cylinder to control each valve. It was domestically available right off the shelf. It was a double-acting cylinder with a six-inch throw. A single one-gallon oil reservoir operated all the valves; I believe it ran about 480 pounds per square inch (psi). You could put the reservoir anyplace and just run tubing to the valves. Doing so, you could locate the pump panel wherever you wanted.” Young went on to say it was an important design feature because regardless of the valve location, any size valve could be opened or closed with minimal effort, and the speed could be regulated—no matter what size valve. They never caught on. See http://bit.ly/2Fl4eg1 for more information. (Photo by Bob Milnes.)

1 In the mid 1980s, the former Young Fire Apparatus delivered custom chassied pumpers with hydraulically operated valves on pump panels remotely located from the front-mounted pump. When questioned, owner Dick Young stated, “Well, we used a hydraulically operated cylinder to control each valve. It was domestically available right off the shelf. It was a double-acting cylinder with a six-inch throw. A single one-gallon oil reservoir operated all the valves; I believe it ran about 480 pounds per square inch (psi). You could put the reservoir anyplace and ju

Read more
Posted: Apr 1, 2018

Fire Apparatus Electric Valves: I Don’t Like Them

Editor’s Note: Every department has its own reasons for specifying certain components on its fire apparatus, including valves on a pumper. In recent years, electric valve use for intakes and discharges has increased. However, there is still a large contingent in the fire service that prefers valves with manual linkages. This month, we asked Editorial Advisory Board members Ricky Riley (left) and Bill Adams (right) to comment on electric and manual valves.

My views on electric valves are biased and outdated and do not reflect current products or trends. Some older acquaintances still in the industry and fire service have similar sentiments—so do those uneducated on the subject. Their opinions are incorporated into my narration. To temper my predisposed views, I sought input from Jason Witmier, northeast regional sales manager for Safe Fleet (representing FRC, Elkhart Brass, ROM, and FoamPro). Witmier previously worked for KME as a product manager for 14 years.

The term electric valve is a misnomer. Most valves are the same. It’s the controller that is either manually moved or activated by air, electricity, or hydraulic power (see photo). Discounting mechanical sirens and beacon rays, I dislike most electronics on fire apparatus. Manual levers, linkages, and pull-rods appear fail-safe. And when engaged, they give assurance that something is happening. Assurance is felt, heard, and seen. It can be the resistance (pressure) against a valve, the sound of water moving, or watching pressure gauge needles moving. You don’t sense that with electric valves. Besides, you can have a broken wire, a malfunctioning switch, a stuck valve, a malfunctioning visual screen, or a burned-out indicator light.

1 In the mid 1980s, the former Young Fire Apparatus delivered custom chassied pumpers with hydraulically operated valves on pump panels remotely located from the front-mounted pump. When questioned, owner Dick Young stated, “Well, we used a hydraulically operated cylinder to control each valve. It was domestically available right off the shelf. It was a double-acting cylinder with a six-inch throw. A single one-gallon oil reservoir operated all the valves; I believe it ran about 480 pounds per square inch (psi). You could put the reservoir anyplace and just run tubing to the valves. Doing so, you could locate the pump panel wherever you wanted.” Young went on to say it was an important design feature because regardless of the valve location, any size valve could be opened or closed with minimal effort, and the speed could be regulated—no matter what size valve. They never caught on. See http://bit.ly/2Fl4eg1 for more information. (Photo by Bob Milnes.)

1 In the mid 1980s, the former Young Fire Apparatus delivered custom chassied pumpers with hydraulically operated valves on pump panels remotely located from the front-mounted pump. When questioned, owner Dick Young stated, “Well, we used a hydraulically operated cylinder to control each valve. It was domestically available right off the shelf. It was a double-acting cylinder with a six-inch throw. A single one-gallon oil reservoir operated all the valves; I believe it ran about 480 pounds per square inch (psi). You could put the reservoir anyplace and ju

Read more
Posted: Apr 1, 2018

Manual Vs. Electric Valves for Fire Apparatus

Editor’s Note: Every department has its own reasons for specifying certain components on its fire apparatus, including valves on a pumper. In recent years, electric valve use for intakes and discharges has increased. However, there is still a large contingent in the fire service that prefers valves with manual linkages. This month, we asked Editorial Advisory Board members Ricky Riley (left) and Bill Adams (right) to comment on electric and manual valves.

 

Valves are usually not the hottest topic to discuss in an article. I cannot even remember them being a major discussion at any engineering conference. The valve does not become the topic of conversation until it malfunctions or is leaking on the apparatus floor. Departments have a brand of valve that they are used to using or that their mechanics are familiar with for repairs, thus driving the purchase of these valves on their apparatus. The brand of the valve can be important on the mechanical side for ease of repair and availability of parts and kits. But, the type of valve—whether it is manual, electric, or air—is also important for the end user and the mechanic.

2½-Inch Piping and Smaller

For basic discharge valves that are normally used for attack lines and piping 2½ inches and smaller, I am an advocate for a very simple valve with the normal push/pull handle to open. These valves’ linkages and opening devices should not be intricate or involve a number of angles and elbows to open—basically lining up the push/pull rod with the valve to offer a very simple and clean opening and closing of the valve. Taking the time to work with the manufacturer at the engineering conference and paying attention to this detail will pay off in the field. Even though I am a fan of some technology, my desire to keep a lot of things basic on apparatus has driven us to invest in the pump house. This investment is an attempt to make things more basic and functional for the pump operator and provide a reliable and somewhat maintenance-free push/pull action. The valve itself should be easy to maintain and field-serviceable. This will require taking the time when reviewing the pump house to make sure you located these valves so they are accessible to the pump operator and the mechanic. My belief and feeling on electric valves in these positions is not a strong one at all. These valves are too important to me for the firefighters operating in the immediately dangerous to life or health environment to take a chance on an electrical issue/short or need to go to a backup system.

Three-Inch and Larger Piping

With the need for slow-close valves for any discharges or intakes three inches or larger according to National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) 1901, Standard for Automotive Fire Apparatus, the valve discussion now always comes up when designing apparatus. These larger valves require room in the pump house and require space on the pump panel, especially if we use a hand wheel to operate the valve. Depending on a department’s operational choices on its apparatus, it can make as little as just one valve choice or be forced to look at a high number of valves—being any combination of manual, electric, or even air-operated—positioned in a number of areas of the rig. The most common large-diameter pipe that requires a slow-close type of valve is the deck gun discharge. In the vast majority of apparatus builds when NFPA 1901 went into effect, this

Read more
Posted: Apr 1, 2018

Manual Vs. Electric Valves for Fire Apparatus

Editor’s Note: Every department has its own reasons for specifying certain components on its fire apparatus, including valves on a pumper. In recent years, electric valve use for intakes and discharges has increased. However, there is still a large contingent in the fire service that prefers valves with manual linkages. This month, we asked Editorial Advisory Board members Ricky Riley (left) and Bill Adams (right) to comment on electric and manual valves.

 

Valves are usually not the hottest topic to discuss in an article. I cannot even remember them being a major discussion at any engineering conference. The valve does not become the topic of conversation until it malfunctions or is leaking on the apparatus floor. Departments have a brand of valve that they are used to using or that their mechanics are familiar with for repairs, thus driving the purchase of these valves on their apparatus. The brand of the valve can be important on the mechanical side for ease of repair and availability of parts and kits. But, the type of valve—whether it is manual, electric, or air—is also important for the end user and the mechanic.

2½-Inch Piping and Smaller

For basic discharge valves that are normally used for attack lines and piping 2½ inches and smaller, I am an advocate for a very simple valve with the normal push/pull handle to open. These valves’ linkages and opening devices should not be intricate or involve a number of angles and elbows to open—basically lining up the push/pull rod with the valve to offer a very simple and clean opening and closing of the valve. Taking the time to work with the manufacturer at the engineering conference and paying attention to this detail will pay off in the field. Even though I am a fan of some technology, my desire to keep a lot of things basic on apparatus has driven us to invest in the pump house. This investment is an attempt to make things more basic and functional for the pump operator and provide a reliable and somewhat maintenance-free push/pull action. The valve itself should be easy to maintain and field-serviceable. This will require taking the time when reviewing the pump house to make sure you located these valves so they are accessible to the pump operator and the mechanic. My belief and feeling on electric valves in these positions is not a strong one at all. These valves are too important to me for the firefighters operating in the immediately dangerous to life or health environment to take a chance on an electrical issue/short or need to go to a backup system.

Three-Inch and Larger Piping

With the need for slow-close valves for any discharges or intakes three inches or larger according to National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) 1901, Standard for Automotive Fire Apparatus, the valve discussion now always comes up when designing apparatus. These larger valves require room in the pump house and require space on the pump panel, especially if we use a hand wheel to operate the valve. Depending on a department’s operational choices on its apparatus, it can make as little as just one valve choice or be forced to look at a high number of valves—being any combination of manual, electric, or even air-operated—positioned in a number of areas of the rig. The most common large-diameter pipe that requires a slow-close type of valve is the deck gun discharge. In the vast majority of apparatus builds when NFPA 1901 went into effect, this

Read more
RSS
First28002801280228032805280728082809Last

Theme picker

Upcoming Events

Theme picker

Sponsors

Fire Mechanics Section Board

Chair

Posted: Oct 21, 2015

Chair

Elliot Courage
North Whatcom Fire & Rescue
Read more

Vice Chair

Posted: Oct 21, 2015

Vice Chair

Mike Smith 
Pierce County Fire District #5
Read more

Secretary

Posted: Oct 21, 2015

Secretary

Greg Bach
South Snohomish County Fire & Rescue
Read more

Director #1

Posted: Oct 21, 2015

Director #1

Doug Jones
South Kitsap Fire & Rescue
Read more

Director #2

Posted: Oct 21, 2015

Director #2

Paul Spencer 
Fire Fleet Maintenance LLC
Read more

Director #3

Posted: Oct 21, 2015

Director #3

Jim Morris
Mountain View Fire Department
Read more

Director #4

Posted: Oct 21, 2015

Director #4

Arnie Kuchta

Clark County Fire District 6

Read more

Director #6

Posted: Oct 21, 2015

Director #6

Brett Annear
Kitsap County Fire District 18
Read more

Director #5

Posted: Oct 21, 2015

Director #5

Jay Jacks
Camano Island Fire & Rescue
Read more

Legislative Representative

Posted: Oct 21, 2015

Legislative Representative

TBD
TBD
Read more

Immediate Past Chair

Posted: Oct 20, 2015

Immediate Past Chair

Brian Fortner
Graham Fire & Rescue

Read more
RSS

Theme picker

2020 CAR SHOW