Robert Creenan
Niagara Gazette, Niagara Falls, N.Y.
(TNS)
Damon Robertson has always had an itch for restoring historic buildings.
In 1985, his parents bought the Barton Hill Mansion in Lewiston, restoring it over the course of 18 years. Their other efforts include a 1902 Victorian-era home and a 1846 Greek Revival Farmhouse in Wilson.
His latest project is tackling one of Niagara Falls’ still-remaining historic landmarks.
Since 2019, Robertson has worked to restore the old Engine #3 at 1019 Niagara Ave., the oldest such building in the city. Completed and commissioned in 1894 under the name Rapids Hose #3, it operated for 90 years until the city decommissioned it in 1984, with its work and the Highland Avenue firehouse’s moving to the new Fire Station #3 at 11th Street and Ontario Avenue.
The DiCamillos’ company then owned it for the following 35 years.
“Many years ago, I was driving through the city, taking a ride home from work, and happened upon this building boarded up,” Robertson said. “I thought it was beautiful.”
Robertson reached out to DiCamillo’s about acquiring it 10 years ago, but at first, they were not interested in selling. It was only after the roof developed leaks, resulting in water damage on the third floor, that they took Robertson’s offer seriously.
Having been built in 1894, this is the first firehouse created after the City of Niagara Falls was incorporated on March 17, 1892. It was also home to the first fire company, where its members were paid.
Roberston said he bought it because he wanted to save the building, with the City of Niagara Falls having a history of tearing down historic structures like this.
“Bringing history out of the dark and preserving the vessels that hold that history are key lessons for future generations to learn from,” Robertson said. “I believe it is from our history that we grasp the tools and knowledge to find our place in this world.”
The first outside funding this restoration received was a $50,000 Niagara County Facade Program matching grant in 2022, with another grant coming from the Niagara Falls Bridge District DRI Small Project Fund. Most of the funding comes from his small business Dragonfly Jams and Jellies, which is based in Youngstown and sells across the state.
Having started work in 2019, Robertson hired three different masons and a Canadian engineer to restore the brick structure. The west wall has been 90% restored, having deteriorated from the weather and a lack of a gutter spout. The ceiling was lowered by two feet in order to save it.
Robertson is using historic mortar to match the building’s original appearance, with decorative bricks being made for the front facade.
He wants to keep as much of the original structure as possible, like the original flooring, urinals, windows, and the current bay doors. Those date from when the building was modified to have its bell tower removed and bay doors changed to accommodate fire trucks rather than horse-drawn carriages.
“The majority of the character is still there,” Robertson said.
Robertson did not say when he expects this long-term project to be complete, as the building still needs electrical, plumbing, masonry, and sprinkler system work. He does plan on putting his Dragonfly Jams and Jellies operations there, with his jam kitchen and a cafe inside.
© 2025 the Niagara Gazette (Niagara Falls, N.Y.). Visit www.niagara-gazette.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
The post Work Continues on Histo