MERRILLVILLE — A Merrillville repairman faces felony theft charges after an Indiana State Police investigation revealed he allegedly attempted to scam the Merrillville Fire Department out of tens of thousands of dollars on repairs to a fire engine.
David Shepard-Hambrick was formally charged in Lake Criminal Court Thursday with theft, a Level 6 felony, online court records show.
In March 2024, the Merrillville Fire Department took one of its trucks to Merrillville-based Hoosier Diesel & Off-Road, a repair shop that specializes in diesel and off-road vehicle maintenance. Shepard-Hambrick is the company’s owner.
Shepard-Hambrick allegedly told the fire department that pieces of metal were in the trucks oil and that it required “extensive repair.” He requested an advance payment of more than $43,700, which the Town of Merrillville paid in check on March 22, 2024. Shepard-Hambrick allegedly set the estimated total cost for repairs at approximately $60,000, including the cost of a completely new engine for the truck.
By February, the repair company still didn’t have a new engine for the truck after months of the owner telling the department there were issues with the engine being made — and the fire department then allegedly learned that Shepard-Hambrick had never ordered one.
“(The Merrillville Fire Department) then made arrangements to pick up the fire truck and had it towed to another repair shop,” ISP said in a news release. “That repair shop was able to determine that the fire truck did not actually need a new engine whatsoever.”
That repair shop, J&M Equipment Service and Repair in Schererville, quoted the needed repairs at approximately $10,000, according to a probable cause affidavit filed Thursday.
“Further investigation revealed that the engine’s oil pan had never been removed, and the factory seal was still attached,” ISP said. “The oil filters were also inspected, and no metal was located in any of the filters or oil and the engine showed normal wear and tear, noting no damage that needed major engine replacement.”
As of Thursday evening, Shepard-Hambrick is not in custody. A judge has issued a warrant for his arrest, online court records show.
Merrillville Fire Department chief Edward Yerga told investigators that prior to the incident, Shepard-Hambrick had done “quality work” on his department’s vehicles.
Hoosier Diesel and Shepard-Hambrick could not be reached for comment Thursday evening.
Shepard-Hambrick was in January charged with theft of a motor vehicle and has a hearing set for May 14 in that case, online records show.
GALLERY: The Times Photos of the We